In a remarkable and candid remark that reverberated through financial circles, Pierre Wunsch, the Governor of the Belgian National Bank, likened his insights to a stone thrown into a tranquil lake, creating ripples of speculation and concernHe stated, “Should the economic data persist in presenting as lackluster, we might be compelled to lower interest rates into a stimulative range.” This declaration not only sets a tone for the anticipated interest rate cuts in the coming week but also sheds light on the difficult choices facing the European Central Bank (ECB) at this pivotal economic juncture.

Since the initiation of the easing cycle in June 2024, the ECB has slashed interest rates by a total of 150 basis points, bringing the deposit facility rate from 4.25% down to 2.75%. The current futures market data indicates a staggering 93% chance of a 25 basis point cut next week, with 28% of traders wagering that the reduction could extend to 50 basis pointsThe rising expectations sharply contrast with the grim realities of the Eurozone's economic landscape.

Recent figures from the Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI) reveal that the manufacturing PMI for February has plummeted to 46.3, a new low since September 2023, while the services PMI has edged down to 51.2—hovering just above the growth threshold

Advertisements

The IFO Business Climate Index has recorded a decline for three consecutive months, with corporate confidence dwindling to its second-lowest level since the onset of the Ukraine conflictOn the inflation front, the Harmonized Consumer Price Index (CPI) has retreated from a peak of 10.6% in 2023 to merely 2.1%. Although core inflation stands at 2.8%, services inflation, excluding energy costs, has been on a downward trajectory for four months.

Wunsch's candid remarks signify a growing dovish sentiment within the ECBOnce one of the “hawkish trio,” his pivot is noteworthyIn the summer of 2024, he staunchly opposed early rate cuts, asserting that “the risks of inflation had not been entirely alleviated.” Now, however, his tone has fundamentally shifted to assert: “Maintaining restrictive rates when capacity utilization is dropping and employment growth is stalling could prove counterproductive.”

This shift in perspective arises from a reevaluation of the economic transmission mechanisms at playThe ECB’s latest models show that the delayed effect of interest rate changes on the real economy has shortened from the traditional range of 18-24 months to 12-18 monthsThis suggests that restrictive measures enacted in 2024 might have overly suppressed current economic activitiesJoachim Nagel, President of the German central bank, has privately shared with colleagues, “We must remain vigilant about the recession risks stemming from policy inertia.”

Consensus within the market holds that the ECB’s neutral interest rate range lies between 1.75% and 2.25%. A rate cut to 2.5% next week would place it just a hairbreadth away from this range

Advertisements

However, “neutral rate” is a concept that evolves, contingent upon underlying growth rates, demographic shifts, and other variablesA recent report from the European Systemic Risk Board suggests that long-term neutral rates could be depressed below 1.5% due to energy transitions and digital investment.

This divergence in understanding has sparked intense debates within the governing councilFrancois Villeroy de Galhau, the French central bank governor, has staunchly advocated for a “data-dependent” approach, insisting on clear evidence of falling inflation before taking any stepsConversely, Klaas Knot, the Dutch central bank governor, has warned: “If we wait until inflation fully aligns with our targets before we act, we risk missing a recovery window.” These differences in policy philosophy are poised to profoundly influence the pace of future rate cuts.

Wunsch's mention of “stimulative rates” touches upon deep-seated contradictions within Europe’s economic governance frameworkAs interest rates fall below the neutral range, the marginal utility of monetary policy significantly diminishesAt this juncture, the alignment of fiscal policy becomes crucialHowever, the Eurozone’s fiscal space is severely constrained: Italy’s debt-to-GDP ratio exceeds 140%, Spain’s deficit has reverted to a critical 4%, and while the yield on Germany’s 10-year bonds has dipped to 2.5%, Finance Minister Christian Lindner still adheres to the “debt brake” principle.

This policy mismatch is fostering new risks

Advertisements

According to a report from the Bank for International Settlements, the total corporate debt in the Eurozone has reached a staggering €23 trillion, with 58% of it comprised of floating-rate bondsShould interest rates continue to decline, corporations will experience temporary relief in interest expenditure; however, this would simultaneously erode banks’ net interest margins, jeopardizing financial stabilityAnalysts at Société Générale estimate that for every 50 basis points of rate cuts, European bank valuation could plummet by 8%.

The ECB's impending wave of interest rate cuts is reshaping the global capital flow dynamicsSince February, there has been a net inflow of $15.6 billion into the MSCI index tracking Eurozone stocks, marking a record monthly high since 2021. However, this valuation-driven upswing does little to mask underlying structural concerns: profit expectations in cyclical sectors have been downgraded for 12 consecutive months, and technology sector valuations have surpassed a warning threshold of 30%.

In the foreign exchange markets, the Euro has fallen to an exchange rate of 1.0850 against the U.S. dollar, a nadir since November 2024. This trend of “competitive devaluation” has raised alarms in emerging marketsThe Turkish central bank unexpectedly raised rates by 200 basis points last week, while Hungary announced the reactivation of its foreign exchange intervention mechanismThe International Monetary Fund has warned that the ECB's accommodative policies could exacerbate global financial imbalances.

Looking back to 2014, when Mario Draghi ushered in the era of negative interest rates, it took the ECB eight years to finally push rates into positive territory

Today, this process could reverse in a significantly shorter timeframeYet unlike the 2010s, the current economic environment is replete with complexities: geopolitical risk indices have surged to historic highs, the acceleration of global value chain restructuring, and ever-increasing costs associated with the green transition.